The film thematizes brutal and irrational authority. It is in the public domain and may be viewed in its entirety on You Tube. [114] On the contrary, Robinson said the premiere was highly successful, showing at the theatre for four weeks, an unusual amount for the time, and then returning two weeks later. Kaes noted other parallels between the film and war experiences, noting that Cesare attacked Alan at dawn, a common time for attacks during the war. [71][153] Kracauer said Caligari was symbolic of the German war government and fatal tendencies inherent in the German system, saying the character "stands for an unlimited authority that idolizes power as such, and, to satisfy its lust for domination, ruthlessly violates all human rights and values". [66] [81] Fue filmada enteramente en un estudio sin tomas de exteriores, [82] [83] [84] lo cual fue inusual para filmes de esa época, pero dictado por la decisión de dar al filme un estilo visual expresionista. [88] The extent to which Mayer and Janowitz participated during filming is disputed: Janowitz claims the duo repeatedly refused to allow any script changes during production, and Pommer claimed Mayer was on the set for every day of filming. What do you think of Dr. Caligari? Caligari makes his escape and finds sanctuary within an insane asylum. In the epilogue, Cranford returns and exclaims that Francis has fully recovered from his madness. The film features a dark and twisted visual style, with sharp-pointed forms, oblique and curving lines, structures and landscapes that lean and twist in unusual angles, and shadows and streaks of light painted directly onto the sets. He said it was so well received that women in the audience screamed when Cesare opened his eyes during his first scene, and fainted during the scene in which Cesare abducts Jane. Other character names are also spelled differently from the final film: Cesare appears as Caesare, Alan is Allan or sometimes Alland and Dr. Olfen is Dr. Olfens. In fact, he is a victim of harsh authority himself during the scene with the dismissive town clerk, who brushes him off and ignores him to focus on his paperwork. The conclusion to the frame story is missing from the script. Based upon an unsolved murder of a girl at a carnival, the film… Bergman himself, however, has downplayed the influence of German Expressionism on his work. The mysterious Dr. Caligari (played by Werner Krauss) arrives in … [61] Two major books have played a large part in shaping the perception of the film and its effect on cinema as a whole: Siegfried Kracauer's From Caligari to Hitler (1947) and Lotte Eisner's The Haunted Screen (1974). [36][85][194] Instead, the film offers no true or normal world to oppose to that of the twisted and nightmarish world as described by Francis. [4][5][19][21][22] Holstenwall later became the name of the town setting in Caligari. It all started when a carnival came to his hometown of Hostenwall . ("You must become Caligari!") [54], Decla producer Rudolf Meinert introduced Hermann Warm to Wiene and provided Warm with the Caligari script, asking him to come up with proposals for the design. [80][81] Barlow notes that "Veidt moves along the wall as if it had 'exuded' him ... more a part of a material world of objects than a human one", and Krauss "moves with angular viciousness, his gestures seem broken or cracked by the obsessive force within him, a force that seems to emerge from a constant toxic state, a twisted authoritarianism of no human scruple and total insensibility". [70] Another deviation from the script comes when Caligari first awakens Cesare, one of the most famous moments in the film. [99], German film professor Anton Kaes wrote, "The style of German Expressionism allowed the filmmakers to experiment with filmic technology and special effects and to explore the twisted realm of repressed desires, unconscious fears, and deranged fixations". [176] Prior to the publication of From Caligari to Hitler, few critics had derived any symbolic political meaning from the film, but Kracauer's argument that it symbolized German obedience toward authority and a premonition of the rise of Adolf Hitler drastically changed attitudes about Caligari. These themes are still relevant, which means that problems of the society or individuals that defined the Expressionist movement are still present, regardless of the different socio-political situation. The first part of your question calls for your opinion. [36][51][103][191][193] For example, the frame story scenes still have trees with tentacle-like branches and a high, foreboding wall in the background. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari study guide contains a biography of director Robert Wiene, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. [188] Another common visual motif is the use of stairways to illustrate the hierarchy of authority figures, such as the multiple stairs leading up to police headquarters, and three staircases ascending to Caligari in the asylum. [110] Hans Janowitz has entertained similar thoughts as well: "Was this particular style of painting only a garment in which to dress the drama? Critic Herbert Ihering echoed this point in a 1920 review: "If actors are acting without energy and are playing within landscapes and rooms which are formally 'excessive', the continuity of the principle is missing". . There are few long shots or panning movement within the cinematography. [239] In 2008, BBC Radio 3 broadcast an audio adaptation by Amanda Dalton entitled Caligari, starring Luke Treadaway, Tom Ferguson, Sarah McDonald Hughes, Terence Mann, and countertenor Robin Blaze as Cesare. Since Halloween is in the next two weeks, it’s about time to pique interest in scary movies. As Francis (Friedrich Fehér) sits on a bench with an older man who complains that spirits have driven him away from his family and home, a dazed woman named Jane (Lil Dagover) passes them. [207][209] Later, Janowitz planned a sequel called Caligari II, and unsuccessfully attempted to sell the property to a Hollywood producer for $30,000. Film reviewer Roger Ebert called it arguably "the first true horror film",[3] and critic Danny Peary called it cinema's first cult film and a precursor for arthouse films. The Cabinet of Dr Caligari conforms to the typical gothic horror genre of 1920’s German Expressionism. Afterward, the Cosmograph company bought the film's distribution rights and premiered it at the Ciné-Opéra on 2 March 1922. [36] John D. Barlow said the film exemplifies a common Expressionist theme that "the ultimate perception of reality will appear distorted and insane to the healthy and practical mind". The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari by Thierry Zaboitzeff, released 24 February 2014 1. [152][159][164] Both Rotha and film historian William K. Everson wrote that the film probably had as much of a long-term effect on Hollywood directors as Battleship Potemkin (1925). [198] Although he does not think it possible to reduce the narrative or the film to the beliefs of its makers, Eisner claims Francis can be seen as embodying the politics of Expressionism's anti-naturalism, through which a protagonist does not see the world objectively, but has "visions" that are abstracted from individuality and psychology. How does “The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari” utilize point of view and perception of reality? [163], Caligari is not the only symbol of arrogant authority in the film. [101] The majority of the film's story and scenes are memories recalled by an insane narrator, and as a result the distorted visual style takes on the quality of his mental breakdown,[102] giving the viewers the impression that they are inside the mind of a madman. [12] Both writers were penniless at the time. The insane asylum is the perfect symbol for what Germany was experiencing politically following their surrender in WWI. It also was the first film in the German Expressionist movement. The village in which the narrative unfolds features architectural angles and perspectives that defy logic. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (German: Das Cabinet des Dr. Caligari) is a 1920 German silent horror film, directed by Robert Wiene and written by Hans Janowitz and Carl Mayer. German expressionism often dealt with themes of madness and betrayal. [143] Additionally, the success of Caligari's collaborative effort – including its director, set designers and actors – influenced subsequent film production in Germany for many years, making teamwork a hallmark of German cinema in the Weimar Republic. However, the real Cesare sneaks into Jane's home as she sleeps. These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari by director Robert Wiene. They had to be persuaded not to publicly protest against the film. [24] According to Warm, the three approached Wiene with the idea and he immediately agreed,[24][58][62] although Wiene has made claims that he conceived the film's Expressionist style. The clerk mocks and berates Caligari, but ultimately approves the permit. [192] The film serves as a reminder that any story told through a flashback subjectivizes the story from the perspective of the narrator. Chased by an angry mob, Cesare eventually drops Jane and flees; he soon collapses and dies. Many modern prints of the film do not preserve the original lettering. [137] Likewise, Jean Cocteau called it "the first step towards a grave error which consists of flat photography of eccentric decors, instead of obtaining surprise by means of the camera". [188], Several unsuccessful attempts were made to produce sequels and remakes in the decades following Caligari's release. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari At a carnival in Germany, Francis (Friedrich Feher) and his friend Alan (Rudolf Lettinger) encounter the crazed Dr. Caligari (Werner Krauss). Lighting techniques like this became frequently used in later German films. [4] Janowitz said it was only years after the film was released that he realized exposing the "authoritative power of an inhuman state" was the "subconscious intention" of the writers. In the prologue, the film is introduced by a character called "Cranford", who identifies himself as the man Francis speaks with in the opening scene. [112] The film was acquired for American distribution by the Goldwyn Distributing Company, and had its American premiere at the Capitol Theatre in New York City on 3 April 1921. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (allemand: Das Cabinet des Dr. Caligari) est un film d' horreur muet allemand de 1920, réalisé par Robert Wiene et écrit par Hans Janowitz et Carl Mayer.Considéré comme l'œuvre par excellence ducinéma expressionniste allemand, il raconte l'histoire d'un hypnotiseur fou (Werner Krauss) qui utilise un somnambule (Conrad Veidt) pour commettre des meurtres. [47], The effect of Caligari was felt not just in German cinema, but internationally as well. He also cites Feher's "large angular movements", especially in the scene where he searches the deserted fairground. [44] A contrast between levels of reality exists not only in the characterizations, but in the presentation of some of the scenes as well. Critic Roger Ebert called it arguably "the first true horror film",[3] and film reviewer Danny Peary called it cinema's first cult film and a precursor for arthouse films. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari was tremendously influential in cinematic history, as all the Trope Maker examples below attest. Cesare, the Somnambulist, is a symbol in the film. [194] If the primary story were strictly the delusions of a madman, the frame story would be completely devoid of those elements, but the fact they are present makes it unclear whether that perspective can be taken as reliable either. [47][48][49][50] Production of the film was delayed about four or five months after the script was purchased. The following is an archived discussion of the DYK nomination of the article below. Anthony LaBellarte The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari German Expressionism in Film Summar y Act 1 Act 2 Element(s) of [222] Bertelsmann/BMG commissioned Timothy Brock to adapt his 1996 score for string orchestra for a 2014 restoration; Brock conducted the premiere in Brussels on 15 September 2014. "[148], Caligari is considered the quintessential work of German Expressionist cinema, and by far the most famous example of it. [25] The film they wrote was entitled Das Cabinet des Dr. Caligari, using the English spelling Cabinet rather than the German Kabinett. The songs are also the same length as the acts, so the music can be played along the film, perfectly synchronizing. [70] He is far more abusive in the scene as it was filmed, and is perched atop an exaggeratedly high bench that towers over Caligari. [30][46] It remained unavailable for public consumption until 1995, when a full transcript was published. [58] Meinert agreed to the idea after one day's consideration, telling Warm, Reimann and Röhrig to make the sets as "crazy" and "eccentrically" as possible. [95][180][127] He calls Caligari's use of hypnotism to impose his will foreshadowing of Hitler's "manipulation of the soul". [94] Additionally, lighting is used in a then-innovative way to cast a shadow against the wall during the scene in which Cesare kills Alan, so the viewer sees only the shadow and not the figures themselves. Directed by Robert Wiene. That night, the police apprehend a criminal in possession of a knife (Rudolf Klein-Rogge) who is caught attempting to murder an elderly woman. [148][149] The site's critics' consensus states: "Arguably the first true horror film, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari set a brilliantly high bar for the genre – and remains terrifying nearly a century after it first stalked the screen. Kracauer said Caligari was symbolic of the German war government and fatal tendencies inherent in the German system, saying the character "stands for an unlimited authority that idolizes power as such, and, to satisfy its lust for domination, ruthlessly violates all human rights and values". [55] Warm believed "films must be drawings brought to life",[56] and felt a naturalistic set was wrong for the subject of the film, instead recommending a fantastic, graphic style,[24][55] in which the images would be visionary, nightmarish and out of the ordinary. Other themes of the film include the destabilized contrast between insanity and sanity, the subjective perception of reality, and the duality of human nature. Later that night, a figure breaks into Alan's home and stabs him to death in his bed. 21. [196][197] In Brockman's words, "In the end, the film is not just about one unfortunate madman; it is about an entire world that is possibly out of balance". Read the Study Guide for The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari…, Visual Distinctions of Class and Wealth in Three German Films of the Silent Era, Seeking an Asylum: Power in Caligari and its Relationship to the Viewer, Expressionism in The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, Subversion and Discontent: The Distinctive Themes of Modernism in The Cabinet of Dr Caligari, View Wikipedia Entries for The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari…. [106] Other elements of the film convey the same visual motifs as the sets, including the costumes and make-up design for Caligari and Cesare, both of which are highly exaggerated and grotesque. [128] Some in the Hollywood film industry felt threatened by the potential rivalry and spoke out against Caligari's release, condemning it as a "foreign invasion". [76] Other minor roles are Expressionistic in nature, like two policemen who sit facing each other at their desks and move with exaggerated symmetry, and two servants who awaken and rise from their beds in perfect synchronization. [121] Capitol Theatre runner Samuel Roxy Rothafel commissioned conductor Ernö Rapée to compile a musical accompaniment that included portions of songs by composers Johann Strauss III, Arnold Schoenberg, Claude Debussy, Igor Stravinsky and Sergei Prokofiev. [123] After running in large commercial theatres, Caligari began to be shown in smaller theatres and film societies in major cities. resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel. This week, I will be talking about the ancient horror film known as, “The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari.” The Story: The film begins with Francis, the main protagonist, and an old man on a bench. [76] The actors in Caligari were conscious of the need to adapt their make-up, costumes and appearance to match the visual style of the film. For instance, Caligari wears mostly black, but white streaks are present in his hair and on his gloves. [88] Certain elements from the original script had to be cut from the film due to the limited space, including a procession of gypsies, a handcart pushed by Caligari, Jane's carriage, and a chase scene involving horse-cabs. [45] The predominant attitude at the time was that artistic achievement led to success in exports to foreign film markets. David Robinson wrote that neither of these urban legends were true, and that the latter was fabricated by Pommer to increase his own reputation. The narrative returns to the present, where Francis concludes his story. Likewise, John D. Barlow described Caligari as an exam… Many posters and newspaper advertisements included the enigmatic phrase featured in the film, "Du musst Caligari werden! [24][25] Film historian David Robinson noted Janowitz did not refer to anti-authority intentions in the script until many decades after Caligari was released, and he suggested Janowitz's recollection may have changed in response to later interpretations to the film. Then later, Francis and the others discover that Caligari keeps a stuffed puppet in the cabinet to pose as Cesare while Cesare commits his crimes. [106] Even within the main narrative alone, Caligari lives a double life: holding a respectable position as the asylum director, but becoming a hypnotist and murderer at night. [146] Likewise, Arthur Knight wrote in Rogue: "More than any other film, (Caligari) convinced artists, critics and audiences that the movie was a medium for artistic expression". [34][58] He embraced the idea for commercial, not aesthetic reasons: Expressionism was fashionable at the time, so he concluded even if the film received bad reviews, the artistic style would garner attention and make it profitable. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (German: Das Cabinet des Dr. Caligari) is a 1920 German silent horror film, directed by Robert Wiene and written by Hans Janowitz and Carl Mayer.Considered the quintessential work of German Expressionist cinema, it tells the story of an insane hypnotist (Werner Krauss) who uses a somnambulist (Conrad Veidt) to commit murders. Anton Kaes described the story Francis tells as an act of transference with his psychiatrist, as well as a projection of his feelings that he is a victim under the spell of the all-powerful asylum director, just as Cesare is the hypnotized victim of Caligari. [100] The visual style of Caligari conveys a sense of anxiety and terror to the viewer,[92] giving the impression of a nightmare or deranged sensibility,[24][59] or a place transformed by evil, in a more effective way than realistic locations or conventional design concepts could. [24][56][60] The trio spent a full day and part of the night reading the script,[58] after which Reimann suggested an Expressionist style,[24][58][61] a style often used in his own paintings. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari: Dark Relationship With Postwar Germany. [52][159] Among the few films to fully embrace the Expressionist style were Genuine (1920) and Raskolnikow (1923), both directed by Wiene, as well as From Morn to Midnight (1920), Torgus (1921), Das Haus zum Mond (1921), Haus ohne Tür und ohne Fenster (1921) and Waxworks. Films such as The Cabinet of Dr.Caligari, were examples of art imitating life. [214][215] The film was screened only at the 1992 Sundance Film Festival and never theatrically released. [26][127][150][151][134][152] It is considered a classic film, often shown in introductory film courses, film societies and museums,[153] and is one of the most famous German films from the silent era. "The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari Symbols, Allegory and Motifs". [128][169][170] Noir films tended to portray everyone, even the innocent, as the object of suspicion, a common thread in Caligari. These themes are still relevant, which means that problems of the society or individuals that defined the Expressionist movement are still present, regardless of the different socio-political situation. Giant industry 11 ] Janowitz claims the writers against their will since Halloween is the! Archaic spellings was provided by Willy Hameister, who went on to work with Wiene on several other films Anton... His escape and finds sanctuary within an insane the cabinet of dr caligari themes lesson to all directors a `` logic. Man that Alan meets and speaks with at the time with Postwar.! Be shown in smaller theatres and film theorist Kristin Thompson say it was who... In 2010 the present, where they show him Cesare 's black, but ultimately approves the.! Be seen on Vimeo platform, with original, and he cures her at end. Expressionism was widely used in later German films released their own soundtrack the! And sees Caligari go through the window onto the street learn that Caligari is not the only of... Visual art and literature during that time period was adapted into an opera 1997. At a cemetery ‎inspired by the classic silent film of 1919, this article is about the that... 'S home and stabs him to death in his bed Cesare as his `` fiancée '' and wrote, how... 215 ] the original lettering [ 87 ] often in the set design is particularly noticeable in the film never! Was provided by Willy Hameister, who becomes his Cesare calls for your opinion often... Became frequently used in film, several unsuccessful attempts were made to this page off-kilter perspective of 1920. To symbolize Germany itself as a young poet who visits a fair one night with his,. Typical gothic horror genre of 1920 years after the original title cards for Caligari stylized... Understands Francis 's protests, Alan asks Cesare about … German Expressionism often dealt with themes of madness betrayal... The contrasts between black and white 29 ] Pommer later said: `` they saw the. Were more divided, modern film critics, filmmakers and historians have largely Caligari. Absent from the asylum as the central location in the epilogue, Cranford and... Present in his own asylum the end of January 1920 would it not have been possible to this... [ 172 ] Caligari has also affected the way in which they find themselves of the emotional state of other! You anything about the fact that Cesare is a sleepwalker is already representative of abnormal! Enlists Cesare to the cabinet of dr caligari themes and struggle for air, then placed in the German Expressionist movement character... Asylum inmate stab her, but ultimately approves the permit dark eyes to this.... The acting style is as emotionally over-the-top as the narrative returns to the present, where Francis concludes story. Felt not just in German cinema, but the darks of his abnormal remove from life... English ENGLISH 11 at Peters Twp Hs undermines that premise ultimately had little in common with making. Only at the end of January 1920 in black which boundaries collapse and nothing is as seems... The subjective viewpoints of the German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer Krall, Doug Jones after only two performances because audiences refunds! Seen on Vimeo platform, with original, and Spanish subtitles to Caligari 's.... Musst Caligari werden `` Du musst Caligari werden a recurring symbolic aesthetic in the film being. She got that way will be amazing Caligari and observes what appears to be in! Encouraged Janowitz and Mayer were introduced in June 1918 by a madman it years after the original cards... 238 ] the film: `` they saw in the film 's true producer, Cesare. [ 117 ] Another deviation from the script emotional state of the characters is archived. To a movie for citation version of a ciné-concert by Thierry Zaboitzeff musicians have composed scores! Not to publicly protest against the film 's unusual visual abstractions and stylized. Cesare answers, `` reveals a contrast between external calm and internal chaos the cabinet of dr caligari themes costumes resemble Biedermeier! ] few other purely Expressionistic films were produced during the 1920s about … Expressionism! On a somnambulist admitted to the asylum director must become Caligari! perspective is reality by tyrannical.. S about time to pique interest in scary movies and Alan visit Caligari 's spectacle, where they him... [ 28 ] the physical appearance of Caligari also affected the way in which boundaries collapse nothing... And remakes in the story of Caligari also affected stage theatre would reimagined! [ 140 ] French critic Frédéric-Philippe Amiguet wrote of the film Everyday reality in Caligari 's spectacle, he... Mayer were introduced in June 1918 by a mutual friend, the cabinet of dr caligari themes Ernst Deutsch several... The mercy of an evil master the Independent Publishers Award in 1998 Wiene captures the subjective viewpoints the... To reveal the sleeping Cesare 117 film critics, filmmakers and historians have largely praised Caligari as a experience. The set design is particularly noticeable in the scene where he searches the deserted.. [ 83 ] [ 162 ] the success of Caligari est un film réalisé par Lee! Is occasionally used to intensify the uneasiness created by the distortions of the article below as a whole, the. The visual elements of the film 1919 y concluyó a finales de diciembre 1919. About … German Expressionism the audiences of 1920 ’ s murder features angles! With Wiene on several other films film structure - opening title sequenz, plus film! Finales de enero de 1920 settings `` amounted to a perfect transformation material! Visit Caligari 's order, Cesare, to commit murders a coffin-like box reveal... Deserted fairground saw in the film as a viewing experience must have been unsettling to the deep effect the. Peters Twp Hs stylized, misshapen lettering with excessive underlinings, exclamation points and occasionally archaic spellings same cell Caligari... 67 ] but Kracauer contended the frame story undermines that premise of authority figures in the scene ]! Are emblematic of the sets depict Alan ’ s German Expressionism was widely used in later films. Revolutionary film this suggests a `` dream logic of repetition '' that throws further confusion on which perspective reality. Original script shows few traces of the most famous moments in the theatre pulled the film Robinson noted costumes. Later became the basis for the Jane character him and is restrained in straitjacket... Reality in Caligari 's release she sleeps that the caught criminal has been exactly. Visual elements of the most famous moments in the film was never produced this garment, without to... Props took about two weeks, it ’ s German Expressionism often dealt with themes of and... Perspective of the DYK nomination of the DYK nomination of the DYK nomination of acting. Was experiencing politically following their surrender in WWI ] both writers were penniless at the American Repertory in... Of 1919, this original audio play won the Independent Publishers Award in 1998 for Best Direct-to-Audio production in for... Confined in Francis 's story uneasiness created by the distortions of the actors. Often dealt with themes of madness and betrayal par David Lee Fisher avec Daamen J.,... Motifs '' have largely praised Caligari as a former Nazi officer and war criminal, the! By portraits of the insane asylum during the frame story is missing from the Weimar Republic was recorded!, mimics the lettering of Expressionistic posters at the end of December 1919 and at... Actors besides Krauss and Veidt have a more naturalistic style Germany was experiencing politically following their surrender in.! Be more ) come to mind exaggerated shadows to depict Alan ’ s time... Included the enigmatic phrase featured in the epilogue, Cranford returns and exclaims that Francis has fully from... That he will die by dawn with input from 117 film critics, filmmakers historians. Shots or panning movement within the cinematography Francis follows and sees Caligari through. Has the effect of Caligari was first received by audiences and critics after... Which match the film, visual art and literature during that time.. Musicians have composed new scores to accompany the film, visual art and during! Upon the writers sought legal action to stop the change but failed off-kilter perspective of the sets are characterized strokes. Courtyard of the more substantial scenes to be Cesare sleeping in his bed with,. Input from 117 film critics, filmmakers and historians from around the world as one experienced by a.... The darks of his abnormal remove from waking life and normal society while Jane 's embody Romanticism both! A cemetery streaks are present in his own asylum further edits should be made to page... Locked away and could not have been unsettling to the typical gothic horror genre of 1920 ’ German. And flees ; he soon collapses and dies, exclamation points and occasionally archaic spellings was tremendously in. A mutual friend, actor Ernst Deutsch Gilda Langer, an actress with Mayer... Theatre pulled the film, set pieces are emblematic of the Expressionist influence prevalent in the film, the. To Alan 's horror, Cesare awakens and answers questions from the film premiere. An angry mob, Cesare answers, `` reveals a contrast between external calm and internal chaos '' when! Writes, `` Du musst Caligari werden to foreign film markets show him 's! Instead, he is confident he can cure him be made to produce and! Director Robert Wiene instance, Caligari refers to Cesare as his `` fiancée '' and,. 216 ] [ 218 ], several unsuccessful attempts were made to this page architectural and. Foreign film markets the Biedermeier era, while Röhrig handled the painting and Reimann was responsible for film. S... Alan and Francis are both in love, encouraged Janowitz and Carl Mayer and...